City desk

The Battle Continues Over the Future of Wolfe Tone Park

In recent months, the Wolfe Tone Park community has upped its campaign to have the cold, concrete space returned to its previous state: a pleasant, welcoming green oasis for the city.

And so far, the group – which is made up of residents of the Wolfe Tone Street/Jervis Street area – has had some success.

Of the 11 objectives it set out on its website, the group has achieved seven. These include removing commercial furniture and the council’s prefab staff toilets, as well as ending amplified music events in the park, which were a heart-scald for locals.

The last event to take place was Dublin Fringe Festival’s Spiegeltent in September. It featured a brass band, and at times noise levels reached 96.6 decibels inside some nearby apartments – similar to what you’d hear if you were standing near a jackhammer.

After Dublin City Council received a barrage of complaints from residents about the noise, Assistant Chief Executive Brendan Kenny appeased them. In an email, he assured locals that the Spiegeltent would not be permitted in the park by the council in future, and that no more daytime or night-time events would take place in the park.

That same month, the restoration of the park was included in the draft Dublin City Development Plan, which states that it is an objective of the council to implement a conservation plan for Wolfe Tone Park.

These two victories for the residents seemed like progress towards another one of their stated goals: to prevent any commercial operations in the park.

But little did they know that there would be no more room for circus tents or raucous events anyway, because plans to install a café were coming down the line.

The Council Plans a Café

At last Tuesday’s Central Area Committee meeting, the councillors present unanimously agreed to grant a three-year concession to The Tram Café.

If passed by councillors at next month’s city-wide meeting, the café will operate from a 1920s-style tram based in Wolfe Tone Park.

Some councillors, though, are already having second thoughts.

Fine Gael councillor Ray McAdam voted in favour of the café, and he is satisfied that the council will conserve the park and return it to its former, green glory, as promised.

“It would be fantastic to see it brought back to how it was in the late 1800s,” he said.

But now he seems less certain that the vote in favour of the tram café was a wise decision. He isn’t convinced there’s a need for a café there.

Independent councillor Mannix Flynn arrived to the Tuesday meeting late after he was informed of this proposal. Although he’s a councillor for another area of the city, he is determined that the park remain free from commercial activities.

Surely, Dublin can have one space that isn’t totally commercialised, he said, pointing out that the Church Bar adjoining the park has a café.

“I really think there’s a very strong case to restore the park to the way it was . . . It’s smack-bang in the middle of town, and it would be a fantastic place for it,” he said.

He is dismayed that councillors approved the proposal for the café, and that the parks department has put this forward before the conservation plan.

Conflicting Visions

The Wolfe Tone Park Community weren’t too happy with this development either, because it doesn’t fit in with what they had envisaged for the park.

“The tram café is a major concern for us here. We have thousands of options to buy a cup of tea . . . We are determined that Wolfe Tone Park is developed as a public amenity, free from commercial activity,” said Ciarán Flynn, a resident who has lived across from the park for more than 15 years.

A vision for the park put together by some local residents.

The group’s ultimate goal was to have the park restored to the way it used to be, with grassy greens, walkways and the old fences, which the council still has in storage. Alternatively, the residents had agreed upon a design proposal for a traditional park layout with a simple water feature at the centre.

This would come in at a cost of €50,000, the same amount McAdam understands has been set aside by the council for the redesign in its 2016 budget.

“Once inside the gate, visitors could meander through the paths as they explore the perimeter headstones,” said Flynn. “This becomes a very different experience than the present prison-yard layout.”

A tram, he says, wouldn’t fit into either of these layouts.

Who’s Being Asked

Green Party councillor Ciarán Cuffe missed the vote at last week’s meeting, but later on he voiced his concerns over not being invited to the consultations that took place regarding the future of the park.

“I consider myself a stakeholder for Wolfe Tone Park . . . and I think our opinions are of value in this process. I’m a bit worried about being sidelined,” he said. McAdam also voiced concerns about the consultation process.

Instead, councillors were presented with feedback from what council management called “World Café Day”. Held on March 10, this was a meeting of the park’s stakeholders, at which they were invited to suggest future plans for the space.

Councillors at last week’s meeting were clearly under the impression that local residents attended the event.

“The local residents were at the world café,” said the chair of the meeting, independent councillor Nial Ring.

But the councillors weren’t there.

In fact, there was just one local resident there for the feedback session, a spokesperson for Dublin City Council confirmed.

The other stakeholders present were mostly business owners, council management and a representative of the local Garda station.

Some of the feedback presented to councillors argued that the city already has green Georgian spaces, and that Wolfe Tone Park needn’t follow suit.

The Resident

Ciarán Flynn was the resident at the March meeting. He showed up uninvited, he said.

There was a campaign by residents to restore grass to the park in 2006, but this came to nothing.

It was this meeting in March which reignited the campaign, when Flynn became concerned that the park might be targeted for commercial use. He even mentioned worries over suggestions of a café.

Social Democrat councillor for the area Gary Gannon said that no residents had been in touch with him over any concerns about the park.

He would like to see more greenery in the space, but isn’t opposed to the idea of the Tram Café. As he sees it, it would be an extra amenity for people.

“The fact that it’s going to be a tram, means it will show a bit of our history and help to pass on our heritage,” he said.

Last Friday, councillors for the area met with the parks superintendent, Les Moore. They were told that final proposals to improve the park are being drawn up and will include more tree and grass planting.

“I am pleased to hear this,” said Cuffe, of the Green Party.

However, the park is unlikely to be completely covered in grass, said Sinn Féin councillor Janice Boylan. “People have gotten used to cutting through there.”

Plans are still in the early stages, said Boylan. But there were suggestions that the gravestones be buried and a plaque put in place to remember the dead, instead.

She is in favour of the Tram Café as well.

“The way I look at it is, it will bring a bit of footfall to the area. It will encourage people to come into and use the park,” she said.

The draft proposals are due to be presented to the central area committee early next year.

Louisa McGrath portrait
Louisa McGrath

Louisa McGrath is a city reporter for Dublin Inquirer. You can reach her at lmcgrath@dubinq.com.

 

Comments

  1. Log in to leave a comment.

  2. deirdre
    18 November at 10:45

    It annoys me to hear a private enterprise called a public amenity – it seems disingenuous – you can’t sit around a café for free – this is privatising a public space. I used to attend DIT Bolton Street and always felt that there was a lack of green space on that side of the city. Fair play to the residents for keeping up the pressure, ill keep my fingers crossed for them.

  3. steve white
    18 November at 19:58

    coincidental name for consultation method ? http://www.theworldcafe.com/key-concepts-resources/world-cafe-method/ DCC trying to control information just keeps backing firing don’t consult stakeholders consult the public.

  4. Pat Abbey
    19 November at 13:50

    Social Democrat Councillor Gary Gannon said no residents had been in touch with him. Might this be because no residents were made aware of yet another attempt to purpresture our public amenity. What an awful suggestion to bury the gravestones and destroy this fine memento mori. Thanks are due to Mannix for coming over from the south side to represent our interests.

  5. Jim
    23 November at 14:54

    I don’t support turning it back into a park because a park would soon end up abandoned again which would attract crime. I’d also fear that a part of the city that is changing for the better could once again become a magnet for inner city kids to hang out and discourage outsiders from visiting. The idea of café sounds so stale. The last thing the city needs is another bloody generic café.

    My own gut instinct is that it should be a Dutch style Markt. The area is famous for its Markets so there’s heritage there. Plus the Church, Nandos, Smiths and Pantibar further down have really brought people from across the river to experience this side of Dublin for the first time. So much so that’s it’s now a bit of a destination. Imagine a Ballsbridge style open area with bars and restaurants lining it, with outdoor seating taking up a section and the rest left open. In Germany and France you can sit on the restaurant-maintained public seating without ever ordering anything because the businesses are treated as guests in the public area and not the other way round. This style of plaza encourages people to linger and it gives private businesses a reason to help maintain the area in a way locals and the council cannot on their own.

    Whatever the decision, the 1970s park should not make a return and the council knows this. House proud locals might imagine such a park as a future oasis but I think anybody who’s ever worked in the area knows what it would really become without 2 or more interests dedicated to maintaining it and without watchful eyes looking over it.

  6. Lois Kapila
    23 November at 20:10

    In response to this article, we’ve received the following letter from Kris Nelson, who gave us permission to post it:

    Dear Louisa,

    Hope this letter finds you well.

    I recently came across your Dublin Inquirer article entitled “The Battle Continues Over the Future of Wolfe Tone Park” and wanted to take this opportunity to respond to some of the points made therein in my capacity as Director of Tiger Dublin Fringe.

    Whilst I’m disappointed that a small number of residents were unsatisfied with Fringe’s activities in Wolfe Tone Square in September, I feel it’s important to address some inaccuracies reported in the piece. Though we cannot verify decibel levels inside individual private apartments, nor the type of instrumentation used to measure them, I can confirm that our Event Controller and production team monitored sound levels from three different locations on the site several times during every performance and that we operated within the decibel limits as set out in our Event Management Plan. This plan was a key part of our submission during the detailed and rigorous application process we followed with Dublin City Council (DCC) granting us permission to host the Spiegeltent on Wolfe Tone Square.

    We worked closely with DCC, An Garda Síochána and the Wolfe Tone Park residents committee to meet concerns both before and during the festival. We held two public consultation meetings with residents and members of the BID. Residents were offered complimentary and discounted tickets and the offer to access the site to personally check sound levels as we monitored them. We changed programming decisions with the residents in mind. We secured a partnership with The Church restaurant and bar so that patrons could access our ‘festival club’ after the performance and therefore reduce post-event street noise.

    Thousands of spectators enjoyed the very best of Irish and international cabaret, circus, music and more at the Fringe’s Spiegeltent this year. Fringe was not the most recent event to take place on the Square, at least one other high profile, city-funded arts event took place in October at the same location and also enjoyed great success. It’s unfortunate also that the Wolfe Tone Park residents’ website only has the capacity to record anonymous negative comments and functionally cannot feature any positive feedback. With two successful autumn festivals located on the site, it’s unfortunate that residents’ positive opinions on cultural use of Wolfe Tone Square were blocked from the resident’s website.

    Tiger Dublin Fringe is the country’s largest multidisciplinary arts festival, with more than 21 years of support for new Irish art and artists in our history. Countless artists have launched their careers at Fringe and audiences from Dublin, across Ireland and around the world have enjoyed memorable and meaningful festival-going experiences at Fringe. We have exciting plans for the future but we cannot realise them with the support of the city at large and DCC to facilitate space in which to hold these vital and vibrant cultural events.

    If you have any further queries relating to our activities at Wolfe Tone Square, please do let me know. I’d be happy to respond in person or by email.

    Kind regards, Kris Nelson, Director Tiger Dublin Fringe Sycamore Building, Sycamore Street

Advertisements

Dublin Inquirer is an independent reader-supported newspaper serving Ireland's capital.

Support our work by becoming a subscriber.

We use cookies to allow visitors to log in to our website and read our articles. We don't use any third-party cookies. By clicking 'I accept' or continuing to use this site, you consent to the use of cookies.

I accept